Soya

topic posted Fri, January 11, 2008 - 3:29 AM by  Ayola
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Guys,
don´t want to spoil the party, but I´ve been working with bio diversity for the past 15 years, and there is not many things as terrifying as Soya!
PLEASE!!!! move to rice milk!
If more people would start asking for rice milk than places would start offering it as an alternative.
To make a long story short so Soya is the one thing on earth which is right now 100% genetically patented.(meaning all the soya you would ever get is exactly the same... which makes you allergic, which prevents farmers to be able to market it freely without huge co operations, which creates mega weeds and kills insects...wheat is the next, 90% patented).and organic soya is not less patented.
Also Soya is a monoculture, it has pushed the desert line in Mexico lower and lower (not reversable) and is now turning the rainforest into a desert (apart from deforestation for growing soya,also as it is genetically manipulated by default, it "preserves" the fields and no other crop can grow there after).
first link I came up with was www.rainforests.net/therapeo...orest.htm but there are thousands, please contact me if you want any more information.
If you are Vegans in order not to tortures cows (which I am) is cutting trees and damaging bio diversity your option?
and if you are Vegan for health reasons
Soya might have full protein but"
It contains high quantities of various toxic chemicals, which cannot be fully destroyed even by the long cooking
process. These are: phytates, which block the body's uptake of minerals; enzyme inhibitors, which hinder
protein digestion; and haemaggluttin, which causes red blood cells to clump together and inhibits oxygen
take-up and growth. Most controversially of all, soya contains high levels of the phytoestrogens (also known as
isoflavones) genistein and daidzein, which mimic and sometimes block the hormone oestrogen. "
news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4115506.stm
...and all this information is out for more than ten years.

Dear Vegan Family,
would love to hear any comments.

Sister Ayola
posted by:
Ayola
Spain
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Soya

    Sun, January 13, 2008 - 7:29 PM
    blah, blah, blah. we're not the problem dude. it's the assholes that feed soy to cows that are causing the problems. the amount of soy grown for humans is tiny compared to that grown as animal feed. if you want to make a change, stop eating meat. i assume that we've all taken that step, as this is th "vegan cooking tribe".

    now, if you want to talk about cooking soy i'd be down. lets carry on. if you want to continue this debate we should take it to "go vegan". that is the proper forum. here we get along. there we argue.
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: Soya

      Sun, January 13, 2008 - 7:37 PM
      I bought almond milk today instead of my usual soy milk.
    • Re: Soya

      Wed, January 16, 2008 - 12:49 AM
      yes we are the problem!!! and anyway its about an ingredient, so relevant. dont eat or drink the stuff and use alternatives, nuff said.

      no need for sarcasm either chop..., its off topic!?
      • Re: Soya

        Wed, January 16, 2008 - 8:22 AM
        dræyk, meet chopper. chopper, dræyk.

        :P
        • Re: Soya

          Wed, January 16, 2008 - 5:10 PM
          i got some soy flower today, so i can make my own soy pasta. i'm even deep frying tofu and reducing a box of soy milk to make a "chicken" alfredo sauce. i can't wait for my soycream dessert! you guys thing they make tofu flavored tooth paste?
          • Unsu...
             

            Re: Soya

            Wed, January 16, 2008 - 7:52 PM
            what part of this is hard to understand?
            more than 60% of all soy and corn grown in the world is grown TO FEED ANIMALS raised for their flesh.
            and more than 90% of all GMO corn and soy is grown for animal feed.

            in fact GMO corn and soy EXISTS because animal agriculture wanted it.
            they invented it.

            While it is true that organic soy and corn are not necessarilly grown in companion planting, and may still be grown in mono culture...but chances are the impact on the soil of ORGANIC corn and soy (which is the only kind that I ever buy) is not as bad as all that. Plus the volumes are just NOWHERE NEAR what the volumes are for animal agriculture.

            There is no tofu company that is clear-cutting entire forests in Brazil to grow organic soy.

            give me a P a E - R - S - P - E - C - T - I - V - E

            okay?
            buy local, buy organic, and soon buy stock-free organic, (I'm hoping farmers will soon use the term "with nature", as in working with nature rather than being at odds with her)

            But soy could easily be grown in this way. And many organic farms are very close (as close as organic tomato, strawberry and spinach farms are) Soy has been grown throughout Asia for more than 10 thousand years.

            It's true that the whole organic farming industry needs to be reformed (there are many issues ranging from labour, to natural flora and fauna and biodiversity as well as the use of animal products in agriculture) but many organic farms have a pretty low impact... and definitely they are not to blame for what the huge soy producers owned by large agribusiness (FOR ANIMAL AGRICULTURE) are doing.

            and to make that link is akin to the "Bush wears grey pants, you wear grey pants, you are Bush" logic


            so PLEASE spare us the "soy is the devil" speeches.

            It's typical misdirection. Many companies who grow soy are the devil (and mopst of these devil companies grow soy for animal feed and also partly for by-products like soy lecithin and soy additives in overly processed (mostly non-vegan) foods.

            So those companies are the devil that does not make soy bad...it just means that THEIR methods are bad.

            Soy can and is grown sustainably and well by organic farmers.

            So I think your problem Aloya is with large agribusiness, and not with us vegans (3% of the population and WE are the problem...yeah okay, whatever)

            Perhaps vegans are easier to reach than large agribusiness so you can feel more satisfied bitching to us, but trust me, we are not at all the problem.
            I love edamame, and I am sitting down with Chopper as we speak to eat a super rich soy "chicken" alfredo meal with some TASTY soy dessert...(I wish! I live all the way on the other side of the North America, but damn that home made pasta soy "chicken" alfredo sounds delish!)

            all my soy and soy products are certified organic, so how about setting that high horse free? stop spamming every cooking tribe, and share some cool vegan recipes instead....in case you haven't noticed that's the title of the tribe.

            and when you join a tribe and your VERY FIRST post starts with "not to ruin the party but..." chances are you ARE ruining the party and everyone wished you wouldn't.
            • Re: Soya

              Thu, January 17, 2008 - 8:49 AM
              >>>and when you join a tribe and your VERY FIRST post starts with "not to ruin the party but..." chances are you ARE ruining the party and everyone wished you wouldn't.<<<

              lol
              • Re: Soya

                Thu, January 17, 2008 - 4:34 PM
                i'm going to print this out using soy ink.
                • Re: Soya

                  Sun, January 20, 2008 - 9:39 PM
                  awww.. you guys scared crazy off....
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: Soya

                    Mon, January 21, 2008 - 3:38 PM
                    hey if your not down with the rhetoric r.e. agricultural production of soy, fine, but at least think of the relative health benefits/harms of it. vegans tend to always eat too much of it... as choppers 'lovely' meal implies... i for one avoid all this vegan soy processed crap... but you guys go for it!? im sure alpro and other multinational/rubbish food companies would support you!

                    if you need protein, there are many alternatives...
            • Re: Soya

              Mon, January 21, 2008 - 3:31 PM
              ooo... its soooo of topic to talk soya but ill make sure i rant on about it anyway...

              ps.way to go 'vegan' meat substitute boi!????
              • Re: Soya

                Tue, January 22, 2008 - 6:09 PM
                I would like to point out that large amount of Soy is not good for developing children especially boys due to the effect it can have on estrogen in the body (one of my jobs is as an infant/toddler nutrition specialist focusing on veganism)
                As for adults I think its fine in moderation, just like oils, fats and sweets.
                I know that a large amount of rain forest is depleted for soy but I believe this is due to non organic sources and agricultural needs for animal feed (already stated but I wanted to let it be known that I am on the same page so I don't get yelled at)

                Do people always show their passion with aggression on this tribe?
                Can we be passionate without being mean?
                I know that its hard when a meat eater comes to this page and spouts random "information" but well ya... I think there is another way to respond..... and draeyk chill out on the trying to get people more riled up.
                • Re: Soya

                  Tue, January 22, 2008 - 6:13 PM
                  omg daizee. are you going to buy that bullshit hand fed to you from the meat industry? what a load crap.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: Soya

                    Tue, January 22, 2008 - 8:27 PM
                    Its true darling. And youre right about the meat industry blowing it out of proportion. its not good for children in large amounts and highly processed period.
                    and for adults over processed soy all the time is fattening, especially when soy is fryed and covered in sauces often and so on.
                    Don't miss understand. I think soy is great. I eat it almost everyday in one form or another, but you can't deny facts. Its not a miracle food.
                    Now hemp.... thats a miracle plant.
                    • Re: Soya

                      Wed, January 23, 2008 - 1:31 AM
                      i know, i do get rather annoyed on here... i think i respond too much in kind to the churlish comments other people post.

                      i actually dont totally deride the case for soya, i think all things in moderation, and i do think vegans eat far too much of it. soy is a problem in that whilst it is mainly used in animal feed it is also in most processed foods so its very much in our face all the time. it is also part of an industry that has very real impact, not least on animals but the wider environment and humans.

                      i think the concern for me is, why people are vegan? if we decide health is a priority and this is the diet we want to pursue, one should look at having a balanced and sensible diet. i think most folk on this site are interested in this as this is mainly a site for recipe exchange. however we are all tempted (myself included) by over use of soy, especially in the weird "fake meat concept" and this is basically over processed and not in the least good for you.

                      here a link from a british news paper:

                      observer.guardian.co.uk/foodmo...00.html

                      • Re: Soya

                        Wed, January 23, 2008 - 5:30 AM
                        I know what you mean draeyk, we are vegan should we be eating more vegetables and less wanna be meat stuff? but don't get me wrong I couldn't live without soy milk.
                        • Re: Soya

                          Wed, January 23, 2008 - 9:15 AM
                          hehe... and fresh soya milk is very good isnt it!?
                          • Re: Soya

                            Wed, January 23, 2008 - 2:48 PM
                            soy, hemp and fruit smoothies....omg

                            i am totally gonna go make one right now!
                            • Re: Soya

                              Wed, January 23, 2008 - 4:33 PM
                              "Now hemp.... thats a miracle plant"...*sigh*..... why don't you slather on another layer of patchouly?
                              • Re: Soya

                                Thu, January 24, 2008 - 5:17 AM
                                FUCK YOU ASSHOLE
                                You don't get to be mean just because you an ignorant fuck

                                Moderator- I understand if you delete this but fuck that guy for insulting others!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
                                • Re: Soya

                                  Thu, January 24, 2008 - 5:26 AM
                                  If you don't know that hemp can make a biodegradable plastic, clean burning renewable fuel, rope, clothing as strong as wool and comfortable as cotton and as soft as silk ( saving animals and doing away with large pesticide cotton crops that strip soil), as well as being one of the most perfect healthy fat sources for the human body... than you are an IDIOT!
                                  Hemp is naturally a sustainable harvest as it can reuse soil with destroying it or the environment around it; it is easily grown organic and anywhere meaning it could be a local crop anywhere if the government would let its strong hold go.

                                  Just because a person is educated on the wonders of a plant that also happens to produce marijuana doesn't make them a hippie...

                                  Just for the record I don't mind being called a hippy but patchouly is disgusting.

                                  Jerk.

                                  Educate yourself.
                                  www.rense.com/general49/could.htm
                                  • damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                    Thu, January 24, 2008 - 5:28 AM
                                    "Hemp is naturally a sustainable harvest as it can reuse soil with destroying it or the environment around it"

                                    Should say without destroying it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
                                    • Unsu...
                                       

                                      Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                      Thu, January 24, 2008 - 7:34 PM
                                      Daizee...Chopper is a jerk (and so am I often) but he is a wonderful, kind and super cool jerk (don't argue, Chopper, you know it's true)
                                      if you read the context of most of his posts in this conversation I think you'll see that he was kidding.

                                      his jokes are often rated 18+ but if you take them in context you'll enjoy them more.

                                      As for hemp. I agree with everything that you said. hemp is da bomb.
                                      perhaps the only hemp product I don't like is hemp milk.
                                      but I love hemp flour, and hemp is a miracle plant both for the environment and our health.

                                      and don't get me started ont he stigma. Hemp fibers and all crop based fibers (bamboo, reeds, etc) are the future.

                                      and patchouli smells really nice btw :-)

                                      so perspective. k?

                                      as for what everyone is saying about moderating soy intake...well of course. We all in this tribe tend to agree that we shoudln't eat only soy all the time (and the only one who thought that Chopper's meal was serious was Draeyk, but Draeyk has proven that subtelties are not really her forte)

                                      But soy is not evil at all.

                                      and it especially bothers me when vegetarians jump on the anti-soy bandwagon because that is OBVIOUSLY propaganda by the meat industry, the reality is that soy is the number one protein competitor to animal meats... so most of the information that says that soy is bad for us comes form the meat industry.

                                      now I agree that a healthy vegan diet should be of mostly whole foods fruits and veggies, and my meals mostly contain brown rice, and other grains and veggies, breads and cereals, and lots of fruits...and lots of fresh sprouts and raw salads...but soy is there too...I love tofu and adore soy milk.

                                      and to be fair, even if a meat-eater was to get rid of all the animal products and replace them all with soy (although I would probably advise them to eat their fruits and veggies) I do acknowledged that compared to the meat based SAD diet, a heavily soy-based diet, is better for one's health, our environmenht and of course the animals.

                                      so again it's not that I am saying that we should proclaim soy our emperor and worship at the temple of soy, but when we actively make a point of denigrating ORGANIC SOY products, and spend our energy actively campaigning against soy, we need to stop and ask ourselves, "who am I helping by "speaking out" against soy like this?"

                                      again it's about perspective.

                                      and the "data" about the environmental devastation of soy is all GMO soy grown for large agribusinesses mostly for the meat industry.

                                      organic soy is just as bad to the soil as any organic crop....which is not that bad at all.

                                      And a lot of things are not great for infants, that doesn't mean that those things are bad
                                      I am not an infant, and I am not allergic to soy...in fact when people speak about soy allergies, soy is like number 12 in the list of the big food allergies, number 1 is dairy, then eggs, than shellfish, than peanuts, and the list goes on.

                                      There are many people who may not like how they feel when they eat too much soy, but likely that is because of too much protein, and not because of the soy itself.. raw soy beans are higehr in protein per gram than beef!!

                                      I would put forth the proposition than more than three quarters of people who claim to be "allergic" to soy are actually not allergic at all...they may just need to eat more fresh veggies and frutis, more colours , more carbs, and more live foods, and perhaps not so much protein, but they are not actually medically al;lergic to soy...I'm sure many are, but most are not.

                                      and before people start spouting off allt his crap about soy being a toxic food and the worst thing since the A-bomb, let's remember that soy products have been around in Asia for over ten thousand years, and that some of the healthiest people on the planet live on soy products.

                                      of course it is important that soy be non -gmo and organic...but that is a given.
                                      GMO foods in general is horrible, but why is ti that GMO issues only come up when people aretalking about soy?
                                      soy is a victim of GMO, not the reason for GMO.
                                      • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                        Fri, January 25, 2008 - 1:32 AM
                                        actually my quip was about your sarcastic processed soya comments... but as usual you miss the point. and im glad chopper exists to be an annoying BOI!

                                        anyway i digress, to quote; "and it especially bothers me when vegetarians jump on the anti-soy bandwagon because that is OBVIOUSLY propaganda by the meat industry"

                                        eh, are you for real?

                                        "the reality is that soy is the number one protein competitor to animal meats... so most of the information that says that soy is bad for us comes form the meat industry."

                                        according to who? there are many alternatives a balanced diet is not, as you seem to suggest only fruit, veggies and grains (i hope you include quinoa in that as its a veritable super protein food) but also nuts, pulses and seeds... all of which are great for protein.

                                        eating so much soy and in particular processed soya is very unhealthy. as are most processed foods as they dick about with very nature of the foods themselves.

                                        as to the statistics "soy is like number 12 in the list of the big food allergies, number 1 is dairy, then eggs, than shellfish, than peanuts, and the list goes on" really, says who? from my experience in the food industry is seems to be wheat, peanuts and chilli, but do remember in the vegi/vegan arena.

                                        now i agree that people think they are allergic and most likely have a lesser "intolerance", however one of the greatest food issues these days is, as i mentioned, wheat and/or gluten, this is mainly in down to all the over and badly processed wheat available in our diets. people ate the grain for years without problems (as far as we know) but now? could soya be going the same root?

                                        ps, do try and read the link i mentioned, it is quite interesting

                                        did i mention nettles?:) rope, paper, clothes... and a super dye! makes the best soup as well. the sting can help healing and rash problems...
                                        • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                          Fri, January 25, 2008 - 9:23 AM
                                          >>>anyway i digress, to quote; "and it especially bothers me when vegetarians jump on the anti-soy bandwagon because that is OBVIOUSLY propaganda by the meat industry"

                                          eh, are you for real?

                                          "the reality is that soy is the number one protein competitor to animal meats... so most of the information that says that soy is bad for us comes form the meat industry."

                                          according to who? there are many alternatives a balanced diet is not, as you seem to suggest only fruit, veggies and grains (i hope you include quinoa in that as its a veritable super protein food) but also nuts, pulses and seeds... all of which are great for protein. <<<


                                          Look up any paper that has an anti-soy health claim. Note who funded the research. Look into that source of funding. Generally a few links down the chain will lead to some meat industry entity or lobby. And it is a fact that soy protein is the number one competitor to animal protein, because it is obviously the most popular alternative. E.g. soy milk is much more popular than almond/rice/etc., same with soy yogurt, soy burgers, etc.


                                          >>>as to the statistics "soy is like number 12 in the list of the big food allergies, number 1 is dairy, then eggs, than shellfish, than peanuts, and the list goes on" really, says who? from my experience in the food industry is seems to be wheat, peanuts and chilli, but do remember in the vegi/vegan arena. <<<


                                          Soy is in the top 8, but where in the top 8 I don't know. I would guess just from experience that eggs, milk, nuts, and seafood are more common. A soy allergy/intolerance is probably more common that wheat though. An intolerance is quite different from an allergy, and in some cases can have worse effects (I'd rather have a rash than a migraine).
                                        • Unsu...
                                           

                                          Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                          Sun, January 27, 2008 - 9:25 PM
                                          as usual Draeyk your poor reading skills make you miss the point entirely. I am not saying by any means that soy is the "best" alternative to meat...(or source of protein) nor am I saying that it is the only.

                                          If you jhad bothered to read some of the recipes for parsnip and other veggies that I posted on thsi tribe, I make "meat" from many other things than soy.

                                          what I am saying is that soy is the #1 competitor to meat.

                                          because most meat replacer products are soy-based...and when meat-eaters wish to "replace" their meat they usually use soy.
                                          • Unsu...
                                             

                                            Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                            Sun, January 27, 2008 - 9:31 PM
                                            Daizee. it's interesting that you mention others being off topic....where the hell did your comment about eating the flesh of assassinated elk come from?
                                            are you f%ing serious?
                                            you really sat there and thought, "mmm vegan cooking tribe I think I'll talk about the innocent elk that I enjoy murdering"

                                            If you choose to kill animals and eat them, that's your choice (and your soul)
                                            but I think it is WAY off topic of this tribe, and this discussion about soy.

                                            perhaps you have a need to confess your crimes, well then start a "non-vegan confessions" tribe

                                            but this vegan cooking tribe is not the forum for your bloodlust.
                                            The discussion about soy can be annoying and sometimes overdone, but it is a vegan food item and ingredient (s) so it IS on topic with this tribe.

                                            meat is not at all on topic. EVER.
                                            • Unsu...
                                               

                                              Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                              Sun, January 27, 2008 - 9:55 PM
                                              sorry Daizee, it seems that you actually were responding to draeyk.
                                              As usual it was Draeyk who had to bring up the butcher and the "happy meat" bull crap.

                                              Draeyk! enough with this shit please.
                                              You ALWAYS do this.
                                              what's the deal? do people push you around in your real life thaty you have to CONSTANTLY come on vegan tribes and talk about slaughtering animals and your definition of vegan and all this SHIT.

                                              please just stop.

                                              post a vegan recipe. Give someone some advice put please keep your stupid ill informed and tiring opinions to yourself.

                                              PLEASE.

                                              and I beg you Daizee stop killing Elk, they did nothing to you.
                                              • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                Mon, January 28, 2008 - 1:11 AM
                                                *yawn*

                                                antonie... if you got out of your ivory tower now and again and indeed if your read my messages... i said my dads profession partly inspired me to go veggie in the first place... he didnt encourage me to eat meat. but if you are then at last think about it, same with all food. what i always find interesting is that ive had more results from this approach than your holier than thou BS.

                                                as your intent as ever with getting personal, lets reflect on your totally messed beliefs which are anti choice(read anti abortion), sexist and enslaver of animals (pets) so whatever get over yourself!

                                                ps your comments are as tiresome as your uninspired recipes...
                                      • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                        Fri, January 25, 2008 - 6:20 PM
                                        >>now I agree that a healthy vegan diet should be of mostly whole foods fruits and veggies, and my meals mostly contain brown rice, and other grains and veggies, breads and cereals, and lots of fruits...and lots of fresh sprouts and raw salads...but soy is there too...I love tofu and adore soy milk.

                                        and to be fair, even if a meat-eater was to get rid of all the animal products and replace them all with soy (although I would probably advise them to eat their fruits and veggies) I do acknowledged that compared to the meat based SAD diet, a heavily soy-based diet, is better for one's health, our environmenht and of course the animals. <<

                                        i agree completely.
                                        Heh its kinda having you on my side for once........


                                        >>i think, at the end of that day we all kinda agree and hope we can just be sensible about how much we eat.<<

                                        I think we really do on this topic, well except the girl who started it and then bounced!

                                        Trying to be sensible about what you eat isn't easy.
                                        I would much rather eat my tempeh bacon for breakfast a soy burger for lunch and a soy stir fry right before my soy cream dessert.....so little cooking and cleaning...hehe

                                        but no really whole foods and fruits and veggies and so much yummier than processed shit. I feel like I enjoy food so much more than when I was a kid/teenager.

                                        Well anywayz...happy eating all!
                                        • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                          Sat, January 26, 2008 - 1:17 AM
                                          "but no really whole foods and fruits and veggies and so much yummier than processed shit. I feel like I enjoy food so much more than when I was a kid/teenager"

                                          isnt that the truth! i mean i enjoyed my ma's cooking and dad being a master butcher meant we always had the best meat... i know, not what we all want to hear, but his take on it was: eat free range and organic meat! stressed animal meat tastes bad. he also believed if you cant kill a beast (his words resonating here) then you shouldnt eat it. quite revolutionary in a way??? and if folk took his advise we'd have hardly any meat industry left! his stories of the meat industry and why he left it had a big impact on me going veggie...

                                          anyway just to say i way prefer food now, mainly because i experiment more and can taste food now its not tainted by meat or dairy or for that matter tobacco... when i think of the food i had as a kid.. meat was good but the veg was, at best, decoration... think overly boiled brussel sprouts... yuck!
                                          • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                            Sat, January 26, 2008 - 9:26 AM
                                            My husband and I eat wild elk or deer now and again with his family here in Colorado.
                                            His step dad uses a bow and arrow and his mom treats the animal with much respect and thankfulness as she prepares it and wastes nothing.

                                            I'm sure this is going to cause some whirlwind of opinions but OUR beliefs around OUR diets is just that OURS.
                                            • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                              Sat, January 26, 2008 - 10:26 AM
                                              im sure it will, i respect their respect of the animals.

                                              i believe if anyone has a connection and understanding of animal, takes the responsibility to kill it and eat it then thats a whole different kettle of fish to the industrial use of animals.

                                              for me our relationship to animals, welfare, freedoms and indeed veganism, is all relative and dependent on your reasons for being vegan, or interest in it. i use leather, bones and skins in my workings with animal spirit and my paganism. its a painfull one and not an easy path, but it has done more for my understanding of animals than my many years of animal lib and anti-hunt direct action. we're a varied lot here.

                                              anyway... i might also be opening cans of worms here...

                                              we might also be told off for being "off topic":) hehe...
                                            • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                              Sat, January 26, 2008 - 9:02 PM
                                              ya... i'm vegan... except for the meat that i eat..... don't worry, we eat all the animal because we "respect" it. after all it "gave" it's life for us to have a big happy meal at its expense....


                                              sorry to break it to you, but if you eat meat you're not vegan.
                                              • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                Sun, January 27, 2008 - 6:49 AM
                                                wah wah wah
                                                if everyone doesnt do things my way I have to cry about it...
                                                wah wah wah
                                                • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                  Sun, January 27, 2008 - 7:12 AM
                                                  daizee chopper wasnt crying (im assuming that thats what u were inferrign with the wah wah wah comment)

                                                  he just said it as simple as it is. as did u. it is ur right and belief to eat that elk or deer or whatever. no one else's business.

                                                  but as my good friend chopper said. if u eat meat, u are not vegan.

                                                  thats it.

                                                  oh yeah and amen chopper ;) its so important to clarify these things.
                                                  • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                    Sun, January 27, 2008 - 12:41 PM
                                                    if u eat meat, u are not vegan.

                                                    At work on Friday one of the guys told another I was a vegan. "Really? Do you eat fish?" "No," the other one said, "she's really strict!" The first guy then told me about his sister-in-law who is a "vegan" but eats fish. Uh, no.

                                                    No one is following you around. It's not against the law. Eating less meat is better than eating more meat. Respecting the animal you eat is better than not respecting him. Admitting you have killed him and owning it is better than denying and hiding from that truth. We would never know here unless you told us, but if you knowingly eat meat, you are not a vegan.
                                                    • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                      Sun, January 27, 2008 - 1:17 PM
                                                      i dont get this... choppers the only one who brought up who is and isnt vegan. it his drama, like so much he says, as a commited wind up merchant!

                                                      as far as i can see, someone is just saying they eat meat... sure, this tribe is about encouraging veganism but we need to be careful about getting into a tis over this.

                                                      i guess none of us really know much about each other, at least i appreciate a persons honest.
                                                      • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                        Mon, January 28, 2008 - 8:48 AM
                                                        >>>as your intent as ever with getting personal, lets reflect on your totally messed beliefs which are anti choice(read anti abortion), sexist and enslaver of animals (pets) so whatever get over yourself!<<<

                                                        holy shit dræyk, why must you bring up abortion in every single thread?! lol, talk about off topic...
                                                  • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                    Mon, January 28, 2008 - 3:34 PM
                                                    Not that anyone ever asked but had you, my answer has been and always will be that I am mostly vegan. I occasionally eat wild meat, therefore my diet is mostly vegan and I have never claimed otherwise.

                                                    but I am glad to see as usual everyone jumping on the band wagon and having no clue what they are talking about.

                                                    its so much fun here sometimes I could just pee!
                                                    • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                      Mon, January 28, 2008 - 3:59 PM
                                                      "Not that anyone ever asked but had you, my answer has been and always will be that I am mostly vegan."

                                                      Thank you for that.


                                                      Draek, abortion? Seriously? WTF? You really want to get into a discussion about the definition of life and which side of the question is more appropriate for a vegan here?
                                                      • Unsu...
                                                         

                                                        Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                        Mon, January 28, 2008 - 6:18 PM
                                                        You know what Draeyk I'm getting sick of it.
                                                        I have been reading your crap for over three years now and you have not evolved or learned or changed at all in all that time.

                                                        But I am getting SICK and TIRED of you taking the opportunity to talk about your stupid opinions on these tribes. No one wants to hear what you think about free-range meat, especially not in a vegan tribe.

                                                        and it's the same for you Daizee, this is who you are? fine. You define yourself as a vegan who sometimes eat meat,, okay...But why exactly do WE need to know that?
                                                        Newsflash: we don't care about how you define yourself. k? this is not called the "Who exactly is Daizee tribe" it 's called the "Vegan Cooking tribe."

                                                        So while you may think that a discussion on soy may be "off topic" it may ramble and get off the point, but at least it is a VEGAN discussion...You talking about meat is OFF the topic of the TRIBE ITSELF.

                                                        so that's WAY OFF!

                                                        What part of your sick brain thought that vegans here on this VEGAN COOKING tribe would give two f#%s about how you eat "wild" meat? and it's less about being true to yourself or about your right to express yourself and more about common f#%ing decency!

                                                        The fact is that I don't go to "hunter tribes" and talk about how hunting is wrong and they should all go vegan, I may be justified in doing so, but I don't because a: I have better things to do and b: I am decent, not decent to hunters but to tribe itslef and the whole idea of tribe.

                                                        The whole idea of tribe is to join tribes that interest you and then to respect the people in that tribe. Here it is a vegan cooking tribe.

                                                        SO not talking about meat is pretty much obvious and anyone with an ounce of self-control and common decency would know to edit his or herself and not post about meat on a Vegan Tribe!!!

                                                        You can post whatever you want, but PLEASE both of you, use your common sense and ask yourself: "is this the forum for this?" or "Am I just posting this for my own reasons and/or (and this is mostly the case for you I think Draeyk) to piss Antoine/Matt/MdJgutie off."

                                                        and if you are just posting for your own reasons or to piss people off then PLEASE keep it to yourself.

                                                        Because people on a vegan tribe really don't want to hear about your murderous endeavours. Okay?

                                                        We are here to talk about vegan cooking, not to help you two in your therapies of self-discovery.

                                                        so PLEASE I beg you. Keep your opinions about meat and the killing of animals to yourself. No one on this tribe wants to hear it.
                                                        • Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                          Tue, January 29, 2008 - 1:54 AM
                                                          please keep your sanctimonious diatribe to yourself... its all rather repetitive and uninspired... is it ever anything else?

                                                          you have a bizzare notion that veganism exists in some self defined bubble that you and you co-conspirators have created... you trawl around Tribe spouting your drivel and behaving like fascist thought police... im sure you "read" about it somewhere... id advise you to get you head out of books and onto the streets.

                                                          please someone save us from neo-puritanical idiocy.

                                                          as we can all plainly see, you would love to get rid people who have a different opinion to you, but tough. censorship or course belongs to your 'tribe' but not mine.

                                                          ps if you ever respected people, you would keep quiet, as you're always the first to 'share your opinion' and as to "common decency", you left yours at the door a long time ago, so please dont presume to lecture us from your creaking soap box!





                                                          • Unsu...
                                                             

                                                            Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                            Tue, January 29, 2008 - 6:57 AM
                                                            you can call me fascist, hollier-than thou, repetitive, neo-puritanical (sic) and any other insult that you can think of in that little brain of yours all you want. You can call what I post drivel all you want.

                                                            But at least I am vegan and interested in veganism and vegan cooking.

                                                            My recipes (although according to you uninspired) are vegan on a vegan cooking tribe.

                                                            and check my tribe list, I do not troll around, I belong to tribes that I agree with and am interested in.

                                                            I don't post anything that goes against a tribe. In fact that is why I left the raw vegan tribe and the ethical consumerism tirbes. I am interested in raw veganism, but the people in that tribe insist that honey is vegan, so instead of arguing with them in THEIR OWN tribe I simply left.
                                                            Likewise I am definitely an ethical consumer but the members of that tribe are so anti-vegetarian that I left.

                                                            I am not saying that everyone needs to agree with me, and anyone who has actually discussed anything with me on tribe can attest to that, but what I meant by common decency is that it only makes sense that one would try not to post something that goes against the very tribe just to piss people off.

                                                            If you don't see the obvious toxicity of posting about killing elk and buying "free-range" meat on a vegan tribe, you've either got something seriously wrong with you or you are a liar.

                                                            many vegans disagree with me, and many vegan cooks may disagree with my cooking techniques, ingredients etc, and we can discuss that, but the discussion of vegan vs. meat is not what this tribe is about.

                                                            on a higher level, I may have reacted to others when they post misinformation and insults about animal rights, but while I am an animal rights activist I have NEVER started a thread about animal rights here on a vegan tribe, eventhough many vegans may agree with it, the point is that this tribe is about vegan cooking, not animal rights.

                                                            Likewise posting about macrame or drag-racing would not make sense either (unless it somehow mpacts vegan cooking ;-) and that is what I meant about being OFF the very topic of the tribe...and to make matters worse, to consider that veganism (in the context of a cooking tribe) is about excluding animal products from one's diet, to post about animal products is more than off-topic, it's just plain rude.

                                                            AND YOU CONSTANTLY DO IT DRAEYK.

                                                            For you all roads lead to talking about "organic" meat and organic honey....(and abortion apparently)

                                                            and again, this tribe is not about arguing and dicussions about whether veganism is valid, it's about vegan cooking: vegan cooking tips, recipes, etc (uninspired or not)

                                                            and while you and others may have noticed that I do jump into the fray when someone decides they wish to argue about the validity of veganism, of course I will defend veganism and not let an ignorant or anti-vegan comment slide,a nd that makes sense, unless a tribe has a really active moderator who deletes anyhting that is aganist the topic of the tribe, it is up to the members of a tribe to defend themselves.

                                                            and defending one's self from abuse does not imply trolling or flaming. The person commiting the abuse, the person who takes it upon him or herslef to go to a vegetarian tribe and post an open letter to tell vegetarians to go to hell, the person who makes apoint of telling people in a vegan cooking tribe that she enjoys slaughtering innocent elk, the person who posts information on where to buy meat and other animal producst on a vegan tribe, those are the trolls.

                                                            and that is not cool.

                                                            it isn't about the vegan police, it's about not being a push-over. Come on! you want to talk about meat go to EVERY OTHER COOKING TRIBE!!! you want to talk about killing animals, hunting, or enslaving bees and other creatures, go somewhere else.

                                                            and if you want to preach to vegans about abortion and the connection between abortion, pro-chocie and veganism, don't do it on a vegan cooking tribe, and I would gather that if you aren't even vegan than have that discussion on a pro-choice/ pro-life discussion tribe and NOT on a vegan tribe.
                                                • kt
                                                  kt
                                                  offline 23

                                                  Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                  Tue, January 29, 2008 - 8:03 AM
                                                  You've got to be F***ing kidding me-
                                                  You're going to take Chopper on with that?
                                                  • kt
                                                    kt
                                                    offline 23

                                                    Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                    Tue, January 29, 2008 - 8:10 AM
                                                    Oops, that was in response to Daizee and Draeke

                                                    and I can't believe I just surfed this entire thread to have it's major contenders frickin flip flop on their beliefs.......

                                                    You are either vegan or you are not vegan.

                                                    Please do not fricking talk about hunting fricking animals and respecting them on a vegan tribe. WE DO NOT CARE, take it somewhere else.
                                                    • Unsu...
                                                       

                                                      Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                      Tue, January 29, 2008 - 8:43 AM
                                                      i would like to propose something radical.

                                                      anytime a thread starts getting long, i stop reading it because it's virtually always a pissing match. so ok, good for me. i like this tribe, i get lots of good info and recipes here. but i really dislike the toxic way that so many threads devolve into screaming matches. i mean, who needs this kind of anger in their life? it's a fucking cooking tribe. RELAX.

                                                      so. my proposal:

                                                      1. agree to disagree already, and stop yelling at each other in here.
                                                      2. for those who are prone to talk smack just to bait other people here, can you knock it the fuck off?
                                                      3. and for those who take the bait and allow the pissing match to continue, can you knock THAT the fuck off?

                                                      seriously, it's like 5th grade in here some days.

                                                      obviously if you don't want to play along, you don't have to and i'll just keep on trying to avoid posts that add nothing to the actual topic of cooking, as i'm doing now. it's just a request, from someone who likes tribe, likes THIS tribe, and wants to simply appreciate all that you guys contribute to an interesting dinner table for me and mine.

                                                      and chopper, feel free to tell me to "fuck off whiner". i don't care, i'll like you anyway.

                                                      carry on in the prescribed fashion.
                                                      • Unsu...
                                                         

                                                        Re: damn tribe and it's no editing feature!

                                                        Tue, January 29, 2008 - 8:47 AM
                                                        and FWIW, i have no problem with one or two of us schooling someone coming in here posting ridiculous nonsense (although I would greatly prefer that our moderator simply delete the obvious nonsense OR that we as a group exercise restraint and simply ignore them). it's the infighting that i'm talking about in my previous post.

                                                        i've learned a TON from many of you, and i admire the integrity and honesty with which you live your lives, i'm not asking for that to change or even stop. i'm just asking that we stop having the same arguments over and over.

                                                        peace out.
                                                        • Unsu...
                                                           

                                                          Re: same argument over and over....

                                                          Tue, January 29, 2008 - 7:30 PM
                                                          I agree with you diva that it is not good to always take the bait, and I admit that I am often guitly of that.

                                                          but I don't see it as infighting, I see it more as betrayal when someone claims to be a member of a tribe and deliberatley posts content that goes against the tribe itself.

                                                          it is abusive bullying.

                                                          and I know what they say about ignoring bullies but you know what they say about doing nothing and how silence can speak volumes.

                                                          this is a vegan cooking tribe, this discussion was about soy, and ye sit degraded into this, but only because to post about killing animals on a vegan tribe is CROSSING THE LINE big time.

                                                          I too, vote that we get back to vegan cooking.

                                                          I'll try to take your advice and ignore this thread and the baits, and we'll see if it gets better :-)

Recent topics in "Vegan Cooking"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
vegan mozzarella? sycamore 14 January 23, 2010
vegan cheese chopper-the ... 15 January 9, 2010
Raw Thanksgiving Recipe Shares! Aron 1 November 20, 2009
BAN MIND CONTROL/ DIRECTED ENERGY WEAPONS TORTURE AND ABUSE offlineNative Flower 3 September 12, 2009